Image 1 – Jordan Crandall ‘Drive – Track 3’ (video stills)
I chose to look at one of the stills from Jordan Crandall’s ‘Drive – Track 3’. Drive is a seven piece video that contrasts the history of film against the history of war. He deals with traditional ways of seeing and new technology image production. After having watched a few snippets and seen a few stills from the video, I can tell that one of the main issues Crandall goes into is paranoia. This whole big brother world is the modern version of the Panoptic theory of always being watched and controlled we see being used hundreds of years ago.
It covers one or two other emotions such as tension and how the atmosphere makes the viewer feel quite tense and cautious whilst watching it. The video was made using different video camera’s, including night vision.
Image 2 - Barbara Probst - Exposure #11A - N.Y.C., Duane & Church streets, 06.10.02, 3:07 pm
Probst, ‘Exposure’ series breaks up a photographic moment, of a place, person or event, into several different points of view. Using multiple camera’s and triggers, she wirelessly fires the multiple camera’s at the same time, combining these multiple images then together, side by side. These camera’s contain both black and white & colour film.
Probst works challenges what is traditionally thought of as the photographic image by dramatically breaking the frame, and ‘challenges the conventional ideas about photographic truth”. She isn’t bothered about what is represented, but more how it is shown and how the representation affects the viewer. I think that her images show a fluid representation of time, in an almost cinematic style by fragmenting these images.
Image 3 – Shizuka Yokomizo – Stranger No. 1
Yokomizo produced this incredible series of images entitled ‘Strangers’. By sending her subjects anonymous letters, she asks that they stand in front of a certain window of their house on a specified day at a specified time. At this point she will set up her camera and tripod, takes the image and then quickly leaves. The subjects are told to turn all of their lights on, wear their normal clothes and remain stationary. If a subject does not wish to participate they simply had to let Yokomizo know, by closing their curtains.
To preserve her anonymity, Yokomizo shoots at night so that the subject cannot make out who she is or what she looks like. The images really bring out identity and the environment where both the photographer and the subject come it contact anonymously, as strange as that sounds.
The images are truly brilliant, and the night time light and the subjects artificial light, work well to contrast with each other to produce this end image.
Summary:
I think that all three of these images manage to contrast with each other. The first image by Jordan Crandall, is actually the moving picture and show is obviously quite different in comparison to the other two, using night vision and quite sophisticated technology.
The second image by Barbara Probst, is similar in the way that she is using the technology of wirelessly trigger multiple camera’s. It is opposite in the fact that she is showing the exact same moment in time in several images all taken at the same moment in time and is a mix of both colour and black & white.
The final image by Yokomizo, is taken at night using willing participants in their own comfortable environment and have been asked for their permission to take the images.
All three images are similar in the fact that they are all very voyeuristic but are all portrayed so differently from the technology and type of film/camera used, to the medium of moving picture versus still images to, finally, the end result of both posed and candid, participants who are unaware of these images.